00:33.6
Ayan, para lang sabi ko na healthy living talaga tayo
00:38.4
Ito ha, magflex tayo ng konti guys
00:46.2
16,000 steps tayo tayo
00:50.3
Ready na tayo guys, ito na
00:55.2
Ilabas nyo na, pound for pound
01:00.5
Ito mga kamets ha
01:02.1
Medyo lumipat din tayo ng location
01:04.8
Kasi medyo posh daw tayo
01:07.5
Nilalight tayo ng mga ibang vloggers
01:10.1
Ayan, yung mga vloggers na
01:12.9
Diba, alam nyo na this
01:15.8
Ganyan talaga mga kamets
01:17.6
Actually, kanina nag-worry ako dito sa
01:20.1
Nag-worry ako dito sa title ng
01:30.2
Baka ma-censor tayo
01:32.4
Hindi ko alam yung mga legislation dito sa Japan
01:35.7
Pag nilagay mong fenta nyo
01:38.8
Kasi nung una guys
01:40.5
Alam mo naman makulit ako eh
01:41.7
Diba, alam mo yung sinabi ni
01:48.5
Diba, yung mga gano'n
01:49.7
Yung mga binary options na gano'n
01:55.4
Ayan, mga ano dyan
01:57.4
Mga ka-healthy lifestyle
01:58.2
Ayan, mga ka-healthy lifestyle
02:00.6
Mag-water tayo guys
02:03.9
Nakapag-anakong laya-layan
02:06.3
Ang nilakaroon natin
02:08.2
Ayan, nag-ano na tayo
02:09.5
Nag-vlogger mode tayo
02:11.3
Eto guys, okay, okay
02:12.8
Nagbibiro-biro ako pero
02:14.5
We're gonna get serious a little bit later on
02:18.7
Pag bukas ko ng YouTube ko
02:20.5
Was just checking on things
02:22.7
Sabay pala nagla-live
02:24.5
Si Christian Esguerra
02:28.5
которan libayan
02:29.3
Of course, both are my friends
02:30.6
Not sure, both necessarily
02:32.8
Subscribed to different
02:34.0
To the same kind of
02:36.0
Political persuasions
02:37.7
Mukhang medyo iba yung
02:38.6
Mga political persuasions Sila
02:41.3
Well, I'm gonna approach this
02:42.3
A little bit different
02:45.3
I think if it's a question of
02:46.6
Making sure you're in the
02:47.8
Circulation and all
02:49.5
Six million views na dito sa
02:51.6
Instagram yung mga pinost natin
02:53.9
1.7 million kay BBM
02:59.1
kay Martin Romaldes
03:02.9
sa minamahal natin
03:11.2
nabooking na nga ako
03:14.5
ng mga kasama natin
03:17.2
while you were in the meeting
03:18.1
sa defense ministry
03:22.4
anong ginagawa mo
03:26.4
important things are happening
03:27.9
ako pagtingin natin dito
03:35.8
3.2 million views
03:39.4
3.2 million views
03:49.7
ito yung sinasabi ko kanina
03:50.9
na nagsabay yung dalawa
03:53.2
nagsabay yung dalawang
03:57.9
I'm gonna approach this
03:58.6
a little bit different
04:00.6
I didn't have time
04:01.7
to listen and all
04:05.7
may sarili silang
04:06.5
take on this issue
04:08.3
quite differently
04:14.2
of approaching this
04:15.6
sinabi ni Trotsky
04:21.5
Trotsky was given
04:27.1
Anglo-Saxon powers
04:32.3
wag nyo ako red tag
04:37.1
more philosophical
04:46.8
ang approach dapat natin
04:48.7
negation of negation
04:52.6
this is gonna get
04:53.5
a little bit complicated
04:54.4
a little bit complicated
04:54.4
a little bit complicated
04:55.0
a little bit Hegelian
04:56.9
isisimplify ko sa inyo
04:59.0
kasi ang dami mga iba dyan
05:00.5
pinapahirapan pa nila
05:02.3
yung mga konsepto
05:03.7
I'm gonna simplify it to you
05:05.8
so ang malaking debate
05:10.4
yung mga progressives
05:11.9
nagmamahal sa bayan
05:20.4
may mga nagsasabi
05:24.9
siya yung presidente
05:27.2
ang ating oportunidad
05:28.2
para once and for all
05:30.6
isiguraduin natin
05:32.4
na hindi makabalik
05:33.1
yung mga pinakakaren
05:34.2
ng Philippine politics
05:38.8
kung mas maganding
05:40.2
dun sa lalaking karen
05:46.7
ang approach mo dito
05:48.3
ang approach mo dito
05:52.2
first you deal with
05:53.3
the biggest threat
05:53.9
and then let's see
05:57.6
way of understanding
05:59.0
essentially where
06:08.3
problematic options
06:12.0
have certain level
06:15.1
and responsiveness
06:17.9
nung in-endorse na
06:18.8
si Hillary Clinton
06:21.2
we can hold her feet
06:22.4
close to the fire
06:26.8
and Hillary Clinton
06:30.3
American democracy
06:31.2
pero kung si Trump
06:33.1
good luck na lang
06:36.2
yung Hillary Clinton
06:44.6
minority president
06:48.2
herself is concerned
06:49.2
ang dami akong mga
06:56.1
going back to this
06:57.0
pag-usapan natin ito
07:00.3
if the argument here is
07:04.1
side with Hillary Clinton
07:07.5
and then later on
07:09.1
with Hillary Clinton
07:11.5
colleagues and friends
07:17.1
in demand masyado yan
07:18.8
dito na lang tayo
07:25.1
hindi ko nami-meet
07:26.5
yung mga standards nyo
07:29.2
pero makinig kayo sa akin
07:31.4
dialectical analysis
07:36.8
negation of negation
07:38.6
neither peace nor war
07:40.6
pag-usapan natin yan
07:44.2
ayan na naman tayo
07:45.9
kakasabi ko nga lang
07:48.0
ayan na naman yung
07:51.8
reference point ko
07:52.8
bago kayo maghanas
07:54.9
sa mga comment sections ko
07:57.6
magbablush na naman ako
08:01.2
magiging mas zaddy tayo
08:03.5
tapos pag nag zaddy tayo
08:14.1
it feels kinda like
08:19.4
and I really enjoy
08:21.3
12, 14, 15 kilometers
08:23.5
I really enjoy that
08:25.1
ang dami natin inisip
08:28.9
and at the same time
08:30.9
approach things differently
08:32.0
going back to this
08:33.6
let me put it this way
08:39.0
may batas pa dito
08:42.9
yung mga abogado natin
08:45.1
mamisunderstand na
08:46.8
yung mga nagsicheck
08:49.4
my reference point
08:51.2
sa quotation mark
08:52.1
mamaya yung fentanyl
08:53.1
baka mamaya magka
08:55.7
kalma lang tayo guys
08:59.8
let me first lay out
09:09.9
fentanyl and coke
09:14.0
seryosa na tayo guys
09:18.9
ang biggest threat
09:23.0
right wing populism
09:25.6
than dictatorship
09:29.7
sa right wing populism
09:31.7
meron pa rin kasi
09:33.0
ang bahit ng demokrasya
09:37.3
relax lang tayo dyan
09:44.3
nagkakokonsentrate tayo guys
09:45.8
huwag kayong magulo
09:55.6
bakit binoto si Digong
09:58.0
in fact I don't only
10:02.6
mga journal articles
10:04.5
mga academic pieces
10:06.0
sa Cambridge University Press
10:08.0
sa Palgrave Macmillan
10:09.9
sa Oxford University
10:12.3
sa Cambridge University Press
10:13.4
sa mga book chapters
10:15.1
countless articles
10:16.6
probably a thousand
10:17.4
or two thousand articles
10:18.4
ang sinulat natin
10:20.6
my academic intellectual analysis
10:22.6
scholarly analysis
10:23.9
nung phenomenon of Duterte
10:27.8
na wala akong judgment
10:29.4
laban sa mga bumoto sa kanya
10:31.1
I completely understand
10:32.4
where they come from
10:33.6
I do not agree with them
10:34.9
and I did not agree with them
10:36.7
pero naiintindihan ko
10:40.3
frustration ng tao
10:42.0
malalim na frustration ng tao
10:44.4
dun sa mga limitasyon
10:48.7
self-righteousness
10:53.6
sa Philippine politics
10:54.8
because ang katotohanan dito is
10:58.6
ang katotohanan dito is
11:01.7
ang ating mga ninuno
11:03.7
nagsakripisyo sila
11:08.2
nung second world war
11:09.4
laban sa Imperial Japan
11:10.8
magalit sila dito sa akin
11:14.8
nagsakripisyo si Ninoy
11:17.5
lahat ng mga nagsakripisyo
11:19.3
and then ano nangyari
11:20.7
purong katrapuhan
11:22.6
yung mga ilan-ilan na lang natin
11:23.9
na medyo matinong presidente
11:25.1
whether it's Ramos
11:26.5
ang dami rin mga kakulangan
11:29.4
may mga malina nangyari
11:31.4
well at least with Ramos
11:34.8
self-aware siguro siya
11:36.7
I don't wanna get into
11:37.7
person-person about it
11:38.8
I had conversation
11:40.9
yes also with the other ones
11:43.0
well very long conversation
11:47.2
pwede niyo panorin yan
11:50.2
but going back to this
11:54.9
as much as I understand
12:02.5
as much as I understand
12:03.8
yung lalim ng frustration
12:14.2
hindi ako showbiz eh
12:15.9
baka artist tayin
12:17.3
pero hindi ako ma-showbiz
12:19.3
balikan natin ito
12:21.6
dami mga pictures
12:26.2
may second career pa tayo
12:31.8
balikan natin ito
12:38.0
non-scholarly work
12:39.2
parati ko sinasabi
12:41.8
bumoto kay Digong
12:42.8
at naintindihan ko
12:44.2
bakit siya popular
12:45.9
it was a protest vote
12:48.0
nakaka-relate sila
12:52.6
accessible si Digong
12:54.7
emotional resonance
12:57.0
sa audience impact
12:58.6
I'm a speaker myself
13:00.1
I deal with people
13:00.9
sometimes I give speech
13:05.7
nandun sa audience
13:08.7
absolutely naintindihan ko
13:10.8
so hindi ka tulad
13:12.2
yung mga judgmental
13:13.7
I'm not gonna judge people
13:15.2
just because you voted
13:19.1
dapat naging presidente natin
13:23.5
President Duterte
13:24.4
he did a few things
13:27.8
including especially
13:30.0
dun sa Bangsamoro
13:33.0
tsaka yung emphasis niya
13:33.9
dun sa infrastructure
13:34.6
development sa Mindanao
13:36.9
kay Pangulong Duterte
13:38.7
may mga tama talaga siya
13:41.0
getting one or two things
13:44.5
for tens of thousands
13:46.7
alleged extrajudicial killings
13:48.3
it doesn't make up
13:49.4
for yung kapal pa kanya
13:54.0
dyan sa West Philippine Sea
13:56.5
yung I love China
13:57.8
China will protect me
13:59.0
China this China ito
14:00.5
sobrang nakakaya talaga siya
14:02.0
I'll be honest about it
14:03.2
yung ginawa nyo yung ganun
14:07.8
may pananagutan din
14:09.3
yung mga dating natin
14:10.7
dahil aminin natin
14:12.0
medyo walang kwenta naman
14:12.9
talaga yung mga liyado
14:14.4
hindi tayo tinulungan sa
14:18.0
hindi tayo tinulungan talaga
14:19.8
sa panganiban reef
14:24.2
you don't burn down the hen house
14:25.9
to get the fried chicken
14:27.7
pwede kang makuha ng fried chicken
14:29.4
pasok ka lang dun
14:30.1
kunin mo lang yung manok
14:31.5
hindi mo pwede isu
14:33.1
para lang makuha ka ng fried chicken
14:41.0
so yun ang disagreement ko
14:42.9
the end doesn't justify the means
14:45.7
because the means can poison the end
14:47.4
if the means are bad
14:48.7
so yung bara-baran yung approach
14:51.9
sa foreign policy
14:52.3
sa west philippines
14:53.5
sa human rights issue
14:57.3
na makancel lang mga yan
14:58.5
dahil tama siya sa issue
15:00.3
dahil tama siya sa
15:03.0
a number of issues
15:04.1
agree naman ako kay Digong
15:05.8
na ang laking problema
15:08.4
so kanina sabi ko
15:11.9
ng ating kongreso
15:13.6
ay hawak ng mga political dynasties
15:15.0
including of course
15:18.9
and that's where I'll compare it
15:23.9
control barely over
15:26.3
ng total newly created growth
15:34.2
GDP growth they have
15:36.3
yung mga oligarchs
15:37.5
totoong oligarchs
15:38.2
kasi kung magaling naman talaga sila
15:40.1
baka di sila nag-invento
15:41.3
ng mga bagong kotse
15:42.3
dagang technology
15:43.1
ba't wala tayong Sony
15:48.0
ang tagal-tagal ng oligarkiya
15:49.5
yung mga oligarchs natin
15:52.3
40 richest families
15:55.6
in the Philippines
15:57.7
of newly created growth
16:03.4
data ng World Bank yan
16:04.9
nang may isang dilawan na
16:07.2
saan nga kinuha yan
16:09.2
kasi kaya nag-re-research
16:10.6
yun ang problema ko
16:12.2
sa mga dilawan na yan
16:13.4
feeling galing-galing
16:20.7
alam mo naman guys
16:22.3
international lang
16:28.0
I think sometimes
16:28.7
you have to put people
16:29.4
in the right place
16:30.6
yung may sayo sila
16:33.7
yan ang problema guys
16:35.3
you deserve better
16:37.0
we deserve better
16:38.5
than those reformist
16:39.6
presidents that we had
16:40.7
dahil dami nilang
16:43.8
yung mga dilawan na
16:45.9
kundi disinformation
16:49.2
sa isang academic conference
16:57.1
ng mga eksperto is
16:58.0
yes but it's barely
16:59.2
15-20% of the reason
17:01.8
many complicated reasons
17:03.9
kaya nga sa social sciences
17:07.7
versus structural cause
17:09.0
so on and so forth
17:10.5
independent variable
17:11.9
intervening variable
17:16.1
lahat na nangyara
17:17.1
dahil lang sa disinformation
17:18.1
pagtatawanan ka talaga
17:21.4
academic conference
17:24.4
yung mga ibang dilawan dyan
17:26.3
in any serious publication
17:28.6
in Cambridge University Press
17:30.4
in Journal of Democracy
17:31.4
barely I see them
17:33.7
even publish op-eds
17:35.7
the top publications
17:37.5
hindi ako nag-iabang
17:38.2
I'm just telling you
17:39.2
huwag kayong believe na believe
17:41.0
dun sa mga ibang dilawan dyan
17:42.2
dahil lang magaling mag-Ingles
17:44.2
huwag kayong believe na believe
17:45.2
dahil lang published sila dun sa
17:46.4
pa-Ingles-Ingles dyan
17:47.8
a lot of these people
17:49.8
hindi sila natututo
17:52.2
hindi sila nag-upgrade
17:53.3
ng kanilang analysis
17:54.2
ang kanilang analysis
18:04.2
pero yung kanyang legacy talaga
18:07.6
yung kanyang legacy talaga guys
18:13.5
ang laki ng utang
18:18.5
kawawo naman si BBM
18:24.3
worst in Southeast Asia
18:26.1
yung ating management
18:28.1
from 2020 to 2021
18:30.5
we had 5 quarters of recession
18:32.9
no ASEAN country had that
18:36.0
nag-grow yung economy nila
18:39.0
yung economy nila
18:41.1
yung economy nila
18:47.1
yung humanitarian catastrophe
18:50.3
ng mga pinagsasabing
18:52.7
this country will protect me
18:55.3
yung mga mainis na natin
18:56.3
ah kaya talaga guys
18:59.0
yung pagkakaren pa
19:03.1
medyo agree naman ako
19:05.4
na may mga kakulangan
19:06.6
yung mga dating administration
19:10.3
yung economic records
19:11.9
or yung economic record
19:13.8
even yung economic record
19:16.8
considering what they inherited
19:18.8
and what they passed down
19:24.6
inherited a totally broken system
19:28.3
kay Corazon Aquino
19:29.6
total debt crisis
19:33.0
rising Asian tiger economies
19:35.7
and then of course
19:37.7
Asian financial crisis
19:40.0
but in fairness naman
19:41.2
he got some things right
19:43.5
a lot of things wrong
19:44.4
na mahabang usapan yan
19:49.4
kay ERAP pa nga siya
19:51.6
in fairness naman
19:53.3
inayos-ayos na yung mga regulatory issues
19:57.3
I think if you di
20:03.2
maraming ginawang maayos na
20:06.9
infrastructure build up
20:09.2
pero alam nyo naman
20:11.8
from Hello Garcia onwards
20:13.6
maraming pinag-usapan
20:16.6
nung natapos si Pinoy
20:18.4
ang laki ng budget
20:21.6
namanan ni Digong sa kanya
20:23.8
ang gandang ekonomiya
20:30.1
fastest growing economy
20:31.5
andun ang Pilipinas
20:35.3
na sa akin palagay
20:39.7
sa emerging markets
20:41.0
or at basahin yung book na yan
20:43.1
andun pa nga yung interview niya
20:45.8
even if para sa akin
20:47.3
maraming kakulangan
20:48.3
yung mga reformist presidents natin
20:50.4
and to be certain
20:51.5
yung mga reformist presidents natin
20:54.5
yung nakuha ni Digong
20:56.9
and then dun sa naiwan niya
20:59.1
to make matters more complicated
21:02.5
to make matters more complicated
21:10.1
private citizen ka na
21:11.7
ayan na naman tayo eh
21:13.0
ayan na naman tayo eh
21:15.1
kinaren mo na nga
21:16.8
yung dating presidente
21:19.4
lahat na lang sinisi sa dati
21:27.5
kung magre-reklamo ka
21:31.6
nung 6 years na nandun ka
21:35.2
na reconstruct mo ba
21:37.4
yung problema ng droga
21:45.2
yung mga totoong big fish
21:46.8
pangalanan ba natin
21:53.3
biglang billionaire
21:54.8
may Duterte gargs
21:57.3
dami kong pwedeng
22:01.4
mga panglistaan po yan
22:05.0
ang daming hanash
22:08.7
yung constitutional change
22:10.5
gaganyang-ganyay mo lang
22:13.8
kinarin mo nga yung dati
22:15.8
yung sumunod sa'yo
22:17.9
purong ikaw na lang
22:22.1
best in the solar system nga
22:24.7
kaibigan natin dyan
22:27.7
hindi lang si Michael
22:31.6
yung mga pangalanan
22:32.1
o alam nyo na guys
22:34.7
kung nag-iisip ka talaga
22:37.5
alam nyo na this guys
22:40.0
alam nyo na this talaga guys
22:51.3
talaga pound for pound king
22:52.8
na from jet ski boy
23:00.0
ginaganyan lang si BBM
23:02.5
yung presidente natin
23:09.0
presidente na natin yan
23:10.9
o sasabihin ng iba
23:11.7
president ng mga SD cards
23:13.7
mag-prove na kayo dyan
23:16.7
officially siya yung
23:22.1
yung kasalukuyan na presidente
23:23.7
na ganyan-ganyan lang
23:26.1
yakuza muna na sa
23:32.5
yung mayor ka lang
23:37.7
galit na galit ka sa P.I.
23:45.1
gusto mong magpa-federal
23:52.9
sabi na incitement
23:59.0
isi-spin nila yan
23:59.9
na hindi yan incitement
24:04.0
magka-criticize ka lang
24:06.4
dun sa matrix niya
24:08.8
sa destabilizer list
24:16.1
alam ba naman tayo
24:25.3
sa mga kapidbahay
24:28.7
iba kasing mga bansan yan
24:31.2
sa mga kapidbahay
24:37.1
yung leaders natin
24:47.6
anong klase tayong bansa
24:53.2
ang mindset natin
24:54.1
sabi nga ni Rizal
25:00.7
if there are no slave
25:08.6
may sasabihin ako
25:17.1
sasabihin nung isa
25:18.9
Iiwalay na daw yung Mindanao.
25:23.3
As if hindi nyo kontrolado
25:24.6
ang buong Mindanao.
25:25.9
Andun ba sa rally nila?
25:27.9
Andun ba si rally nila
25:29.1
yung taga Bangsamoro?
25:31.4
Si Haji Morad nandun?
25:33.1
Andun ba yung mga governors
25:34.4
ng mga ibang Mindanao provinces?
25:37.7
Central Mindanao?
25:40.1
Western Mindanao?
25:42.0
Kayo-kayo lang yan.
25:45.8
Ayan na naman tayo dyan.
25:47.0
So unless I see other governors
25:51.7
and other top officials
25:53.2
galing sa Mindanao
25:55.8
sumabak dito sa ano ninyong tatay,
25:59.9
that this has currency anymore.
26:01.7
Yung Bangsamoro may sarili ng ano yan.
26:04.9
Bakit may ganyan?
26:08.2
Wala nga itong TikTok na nalagay tayo ng...
26:11.4
Habang bigla may ano na ako dito sa...
26:17.0
And let me be absolutely clear mga kameta.
26:22.2
Excuse me lang ah.
26:23.7
This is an important data.
26:26.6
Yung blue is revenues raised.
26:31.5
Ang pinakamalaki na taxes,
26:35.0
nagre-raise ng taxes,
26:38.2
National Capital Region.
26:39.5
Yung blue ay mas malaki sa red.
26:42.9
Yung blue ay mas malaki sa red.
26:45.1
Yung blue mas malaki sa...
26:48.4
So, ito yung data galing sa
26:50.6
Philippine Statistics Authority.
26:53.0
Ang National Capital Region,
26:54.9
kung saan tayo galing,
26:56.4
raised 410, I suppose,
27:03.6
Pero ang ginastos lang natin is 340.
27:06.8
So, meron kang almost 70 billion na extra.
27:10.3
Guess saan pumunta yan?
27:11.8
Now, look at the same graph.
27:13.4
And look at different regions of the country.
27:14.8
Especially, Mindanao region.
27:17.0
Essentially, guys.
27:19.6
I'll post it sa baba.
27:21.9
Essentially, guys.
27:25.8
NCR ang nagsasubsidize
27:27.7
ng ibang mga LGUs.
27:31.3
Dahil hindi sila nagre-raise ng sufficient revenues
27:34.3
galing sa sarili nila.
27:37.2
Ang dahilan dyan ay hindi dahil
27:38.7
ayaw tumulong yung mga ating mga kababayan
27:41.2
from Mindanao region.
27:42.2
Ang dahilan dyan is dahil
27:43.5
yung mga super trapo at dynasties
27:45.9
silang nakakababayan.
27:47.5
Dyan sa mga ibat-ibang.
27:50.1
this is a different data.
27:52.3
Revenue collection.
27:53.4
Tingnan nyo sa image.
27:55.1
Tingnan nyo gano ka dark
27:58.8
The darker the area,
27:59.8
that means the more revenues they raise.
28:02.2
Tingnan nyo gano ka laki?
28:04.2
Tingnan nyo gano ka laki.
28:08.8
tayo sa NCR talaga.
28:11.2
Ayaw na naman tayo.
28:12.3
NCR because oligarch capital.
28:15.1
Kuya, nagbabahit ba
28:16.0
ng mga oligarch capital?
28:16.4
Yung mga oligarch capital.
28:16.5
Yung mga oligarch capital.
28:16.8
Yung mga oligarch capital.
28:16.9
Yung mga oligarch capital.
28:16.9
Actually, ang nagbabayad po ng revenue
28:18.9
Mga ordinaryong tao po
28:22.8
So, mag-isip naman kasi kayo
28:25.4
Bago kayo magsalita
28:26.4
Papaya na naman kayo sa sarili
28:28.3
Ayan naman kasi tayo
28:30.3
Tingnan nyo, gano'ng kalaking contribution natin sa NCR
28:35.1
So, ang implication na ito ay very clear
28:38.4
Even sa rice production
28:39.9
Thanks pala kay Sir Ivan
28:42.4
Kasi may pinost din siya dyan
28:43.7
But I also had my other debt
28:46.9
Ipo-post ko rin dyan mga kamets
28:48.9
Don't worry about it
28:49.9
And you can go and google it on yourself
28:53.0
Maraming ebidensya
28:55.1
Na yung mga trapos at dynasties
28:57.0
Doon sa mga ibang riyon ng country natin
28:59.0
Sarili lang nilang iniisip nila
29:01.1
Yung pamilya lang nilang iniisip nila
29:02.8
I mean, I'm not gonna name names
29:04.6
But I've been to many provinces
29:06.0
Beautiful tourist destinations
29:08.1
Na alam ko ang laki ng kinikita nila sa mga turista
29:13.0
Walang matinong asfalte
29:15.3
Walang matinong infrastruktura
29:16.7
O alam natin saan pumunta yung pera
29:19.6
So, the reality is actually
29:21.4
Sinesubsidize ng ordinary tax payers sa NCR
29:25.0
Yung mga iba't ibang probinsya across the country
29:29.0
And unfortunately, dahil sa Mindanao
29:30.8
Dahil napaka lakas yung hawak ng mga dynasties and warlords
29:35.1
At dahil napaka concentrated yung power
29:39.1
At napakahina yung mga institutions
29:42.7
Napakahina yung mga institutions
29:46.7
Umaasa sila sa subsidy
29:49.1
So, in a federalized system, guys
29:51.5
Ang mangyayari dito
29:52.5
Yung ngayong filter sa TikTok
29:53.8
Pag ganyan, kung may shades na ako
29:55.1
May ganyan, biglang
29:56.0
So, kung mag-federalize tayo, guys
29:58.8
Lalong magka-concentrate yung wealth sa Metro Manila
30:02.9
And NCR and developed regions
30:04.2
Because hindi na kailangan mag-subsidize ng ibang region
30:06.7
Kanya-kanyang diskarta na yan
30:08.3
Yun kasi dapat nangyisipin
30:09.8
Yung mga magagaling at malalaking business
30:12.2
Lalong pupunta sa Manila yan
30:13.7
So, to give you a very good example
30:15.8
Look at the United States
30:16.7
Ang tagal na nilang federal
30:18.9
Ngayon, alam ko, yung mga iba dyan na nag-United States
30:22.3
Nagka-California, New York lang
30:24.0
Now, punta kayo dun sa mga ibang estado
30:26.5
I'm not gonna say which states
30:27.7
But you know which states
30:28.6
You go to many states
30:29.9
In the middle of America
30:30.8
South of, but north of United States
30:32.7
Ang layo nung agwat nila
30:35.0
Dun sa, hindi lang kultura
30:37.3
Yung levels of development sa New York
30:40.5
Sa mga big coastal cities
30:45.0
Pinakamayaman na bansa
30:46.1
By some standards
30:46.7
At least in terms of size of the GDP in nominal terms
30:48.9
Kitang-kita mga laki nung agwat
30:51.1
Kaya yung mga magagaling na bata
30:55.0
Matatali nung bata
30:56.0
Pupunta na lang sila sa New York
30:58.3
I mean, kapang lang may kilala tayo
31:01.4
At pumunta nag-aral sa California
31:04.9
Usually, ganun yung story
31:06.4
O galing sa mahirap na lugar sa Midwest
31:09.3
Pupunta mag-aral sa Yale
31:11.6
And then, mag-stay na dun
31:13.5
Hindi na bumabalik
31:14.2
So, we have very clear examples
31:16.7
In very, very developed countries
31:19.1
Na yung mga inequalities will persist over time
31:22.6
At yung mga syunga dyan
31:28.3
Pag binuksan natin
31:29.6
Ang sarili natin sa lahat ng foreign investors
31:31.4
Magically maging okay tayo
31:35.0
Ang China at Vietnam
31:36.2
Na napaka-bilis ng growth nila
31:37.9
Ang dami nilang capital
31:39.4
Foreign capital restrictions
31:41.0
Ang isang dahilan
31:42.4
Na napaka-successful yung mga country na yan
31:44.2
Aside from geography and geopolitics
31:45.7
Is that they have a lot of capital restrictions
31:46.7
Is actually trade and industrial policy
31:48.9
Now, if you want to know more about it
31:51.1
Just go to YouTube
31:53.0
Industrial policy
31:56.1
Yung mga explanation natin
31:57.4
Why those factors are important
31:59.7
I promise you guys to be serious
32:01.6
To be serious about this topic
32:02.9
Eh, parang penta nalaga na
32:05.9
So, walang kwenta yung argument na
32:10.4
Pag nag-ganyan tayo
32:11.3
Automatic lahat ang problema natin na hindi mawala
32:14.5
I completely understand yung sentimento
32:17.3
At yung mga ibang riyon ng bansa natin
32:19.2
Na gusto mong humiwala or something
32:20.5
I completely understand
32:21.4
I'll tell you what
32:22.4
I'll tell you what
32:24.0
Tagabagyo ako, di ba?
32:25.9
Kami nga ng Tagabagyo
32:27.0
Meron din kami minsan inis sa mga Tagamanila
32:32.5
Apoy nga kastay-kastay
32:33.7
O, naging nga nyamet
32:37.7
Yung mga ilokan dyan
32:40.1
Alam nyo na eh, di ba?
32:40.9
Yung mga sinisabi na
32:42.8
Pag pumunta ako sa Bagyo
32:44.7
Nag-iilokanan nalang ako
32:50.5
May meron talagang resentment
32:54.4
I understand the sentiment
32:58.4
Doesn't get you national success
33:00.7
Parang gilas yan eh
33:02.2
Hindi pwede puro puso lang
33:03.7
Kailangan talento
33:04.7
Kailangan diskarte
33:05.7
Kailangan practice
33:06.7
Kailangan magaling na coach
33:08.2
Hindi pwede purong
33:09.4
At yun ang problema ko
33:11.3
Ang ating demokrasya
33:13.4
Is a popularity contest
33:16.3
Syo nga yung argument
33:17.6
Iyan tas ang popularity
33:20.0
Minsan nga yung ma-popular
33:22.3
Yung pa yung mga palpak eh
33:24.5
Madali naman yung popular
33:25.5
Pamigay-migay ka lang
33:27.4
Kawawa na yung bansa
33:29.5
Mga galing land leaders
33:31.3
Because they do the difficult things
33:33.1
I'll give you an example
33:34.5
It's like having a good parent
33:35.6
Di ba yung isang parent mo
33:41.8
Gustong-gusto mo siya
33:43.0
Tapos yung isang parent mo
33:45.9
Maging kawawa yung pamilya
33:50.2
Yung mga excess expenditure nyo
33:53.1
Sino mas popular sa kanilang dalawa?
33:55.4
Yung irresponsable
33:56.4
Or yung responsable?
33:59.8
Yung irresponsable
34:01.9
Do you understand what I'm saying?
34:03.6
So popularity does not equate
34:07.3
Sometimes inversely related
34:09.1
Yung dalawa na yan
34:11.3
You have many examples
34:12.3
Hindi ko na sasabihin na
34:15.0
Yung mga dictator na yan
34:15.9
But many problematic people
34:17.5
Had very high approval rating
34:20.3
Hindi ito popularity contest
34:22.2
This is about competence
34:23.6
Alam mo dito sa Japan
34:26.0
Alam mo yung approval rating
34:27.3
Ng prime minister nila
34:31.6
So you're telling me
34:35.6
Ay 4-5 times more competent
34:41.4
Magtawalan na lang tayo dito
34:43.7
Do you get what I'm saying?
34:44.5
Kaya dumb yung argument
34:45.8
Kung mataas yung popularity
34:47.5
Mas competent din
34:48.5
It's a dumb argument
34:58.9
I completely understand
35:02.0
Kasi sentiments comes from
35:03.2
Decades and history of frustration
35:11.4
Doon sa kapilang kampo?
35:14.1
Sometimes pwede ka rin
35:15.4
Na mababa rin approval
35:18.2
Hindi naman mutually exclusive yan
35:19.7
But I'm just saying
35:20.5
Just because mataas na approval mo
35:21.9
Hindi ibig sabihin na magaling ka
35:23.1
In fact sometimes
35:24.4
It means the opposite
35:25.5
But it is very possible also
35:28.6
Na mababa yung approval mo
35:33.6
I'm not discounting that
35:36.2
Yung prime minister dito
35:37.0
I don't think he's incompetent
35:38.2
Pero yung approval niya
35:48.9
1-half competence of Trump
35:52.4
Do you get what I'm saying?
35:54.1
Kaya nga stupid yung argument na yan
35:56.2
Sorry again to say it
35:57.1
But it's really ridiculous
35:58.6
Nakakaya yung mga ganyan arguments
36:00.8
It doesn't belong
36:02.0
In a proper intelligent conversation
36:05.3
Let's just be very clear about that
36:07.4
Let's go to the second part of our discussion
36:09.7
Remember I said negation of negation
36:12.3
That automatically support naman naman yung kabla?
36:16.9
Yung mga ka-Pepsi dyan
36:18.0
Now I've been absolutely clear
36:23.2
That I do believe
36:24.7
That our current president
36:26.8
Is doing the right things
36:27.9
At West Philippine Sea
36:28.8
Now we can have a long discussion
36:30.8
About the circumstances of that
36:32.5
Oh dahil ba yan sa real
36:33.9
Ano magpapogi sa West
36:36.1
We can have a long conversation
36:38.3
But in terms of effect
36:39.3
And formal policy
36:40.7
I think President Ferdinand Marco Jr.
36:42.5
Is doing the right thing
36:43.4
Sa West Philippine Sea
36:45.4
Is it free of risk?
36:47.3
Is it 100% correct?
36:49.7
But is it in general
36:51.6
In the right direction?
36:54.8
So I'm very clear about that
36:56.2
But does that mean
36:58.5
Na just because gusto natin
37:00.4
Yung foreign policy niya
37:01.5
Or just because mas gusto mo siya
37:03.6
Rather than yung kabila
37:05.7
Okay ka na sa kanya 100%?
37:09.7
Okay ka na sa Maharlika Fund?
37:12.0
People's Initiative?
37:13.5
Although in fairness to be fair to the president
37:15.9
And so on and so forth
37:19.0
So on and so forth
37:20.2
I appreciate yung paglaya
37:25.9
Sorry gabi na guys
37:28.5
I appreciate yung recalibration of drug war
37:34.5
But I need to see way way way more than this
37:38.8
Including on the economic front
37:40.2
Including in terms of inflation management
37:42.3
Quality infrastructure
37:46.1
Bringing high quality investments
37:48.3
So on and so forth
37:51.4
I'll give you good score
37:53.2
But I'm still gonna look at other issues
37:57.8
Actually one issue I also have
37:59.2
With President Marco Jr. right now
38:01.4
Dapat mas forceful yung response niya
38:15.1
Kasi kung conflict avoidan ka
38:19.2
You're inviting essentially
38:30.1
And as I said nga
38:31.2
One of the biggest paradoxes of our politics
38:33.9
The conflict avoidant president
38:36.1
Is also versing a lot of crisis right and left
38:38.6
Because the more conflict avoidant you are
38:40.5
The more you're welcoming
38:43.4
The more you're welcoming challenges and conflicts
38:46.2
Iyan na lang natin
38:46.9
Block lang natin itong mga ano
38:48.3
May mga unguy dito
38:52.7
Block natin itong mga
38:57.1
Okay okay okay okay
39:00.4
Block din natin ito si
39:02.8
Obvious na obvious na fake
39:08.3
Two thousand ang kinafollow niya
39:16.4
Okay may mga low life dyan
39:18.1
Kailangan nila kumita guys
39:20.3
Isa rin ang issue ko
39:22.4
Marami pa rin ng Trolls
39:24.0
Kasi alam ko mataas ang inflation
39:25.5
Kailangan kumita ng iba
39:26.5
Kaya pagbigyan natin
39:31.3
Hindi na hindi natin kailangan moderate
39:33.1
Actually guys I enjoy it
39:36.0
Kung naniwala ka talaga sa sinasabi mo
39:38.0
Kung may conviction ka sa buhay
39:40.2
Di ka ma-intimidate
39:41.1
In fact matutuwa ka pa
39:43.3
Mga low life guys
39:44.3
Low life na ganyan
39:46.4
And I feel flattered
39:47.7
And thank you for pushing up my engagement
39:49.5
But going back to this
39:55.7
Kaya kanina may survey tayo
39:57.3
Sabi ko ano dapat
39:58.1
Ang response ni BBM dito
40:01.5
Medyo next level na to eh
40:07.7
Openly akusahan ka na
40:10.0
Gumagamit ka ng droga
40:11.6
Which you know the president
40:13.7
I'm not even gonna dignify
40:14.9
That kind of question
40:15.9
Pwede natin pag-usapan
40:17.2
Ano yung kasaysayan
40:19.1
But you know what
40:22.2
There's no evidence that
40:24.0
You know what I'm gonna say
40:28.7
If you have something
40:29.8
But as far as I know
40:31.4
Hindi eto yung sabog
40:33.9
Sa foreign policy natin
40:35.1
Hindi eto yung sabog na
40:36.4
Hindi niya makompleto
40:37.3
Yung sasabihin niya
40:38.0
Hindi eto yung sabog na
40:40.2
Magbibigay ng speech
40:47.2
Kailangan magpahanong yung isa
40:49.6
Sir magkano ka naman dyan
40:52.8
Pahinga pahinga naman dyan
40:54.9
Balikan natin ito
41:02.2
That has to be fixed
41:04.0
There's a lot that is lacking
41:07.7
Kaya nga ang point ko is
41:11.1
Ang challenge talaga dito is
41:15.0
Totoong oposisyon
41:16.4
Now alam ko maraming galit sa akin
41:18.0
Sa totoong oposisyon
41:19.1
Actually hindi eh
41:20.9
Ang mga galit sa akin ay
41:25.7
Yung mga galit sa akin
41:27.6
Nag binooking ko talaga
41:28.7
Na hindi sila updated
41:29.9
Hindi sila upgraded
41:31.4
Now I'm sorry guys
41:38.5
You're really a good educator
41:39.8
You're compassionate
41:41.4
You're understanding
41:43.7
You will be tough
41:44.2
When you need to be tough
41:45.9
To be the best version of themselves
41:47.7
In a very judicious way
41:50.3
Sobrang nainis talaga ako dati
41:52.8
Pinipilit pa rin yung
41:55.3
Disinformation ito
41:56.8
Disinformation ito
41:57.9
Pinipilit pa rin yung argumento na
41:59.4
Nung nanalo si Marcos Jr.
42:01.1
Ito ng katapusan ng Pilipinas
42:07.9
Ang ibisa ng puerile
42:09.5
It's intellectually puerile
42:10.9
It's politically self-defeating
42:12.6
I'll be just brutally honest
42:15.1
Hindi nila ako inimbita
42:16.2
Sa mga events nila
42:23.0
May sasabihin naman ako
42:26.7
Pero control ko na
42:27.9
Sabihin naman nila
42:29.0
Mayabang tong batang to
42:31.1
Ayoko yung pahambal effect
42:32.6
Na hambog naman talaga
42:35.7
Na hindi ka pahambal effect
42:37.5
Pero actually deep inside
42:38.8
You're willing to learn
42:39.9
In fact that's the reason
42:40.9
Why I'm open to collaboration
42:42.2
Whether ito yung sea crush
42:43.7
Na si Ronald Alden
42:51.4
Parang mas tama na naman ako
42:53.6
Tingnan niya naman
42:54.8
Yung response ni BBM
43:00.8
Okay daw ang lahat
43:03.6
And then beso beso
43:06.3
Buti pa nga yung first lady
43:09.1
O medyo nagpakita
43:12.6
Gumanon na lang siya
43:15.1
Ipo-post ko rin yung video
43:17.0
Kasi ang daan ko kong ginagawa
43:20.5
The president has to draw the line
43:22.5
You have to show you're the president
43:23.6
You have the mandate of people
43:24.8
Yung tangal ng opisina
43:28.1
Sabi nung isang kapatid niya
43:29.8
Na nag-apologist naman daw
43:31.6
Yung anak ni ganito
43:36.8
Decisive leadership
43:37.7
But the same also goes
43:40.2
For the opposition
43:40.8
They have to also show
43:41.8
Decisive leadership
43:43.7
Kung talagang humble ka
43:45.3
You're willing to listen
43:46.2
I won't say corrected
43:48.0
Get different perspective
43:50.7
Conversation namin ni
43:52.8
Ronald de Amas Capon
43:56.4
May mga efforts naman
43:57.2
Behind the scenes
43:58.2
One thing that I'm
43:59.1
I'm very happy about
44:04.4
Openness to the idea
44:06.3
Of a grand opposition
44:09.4
From Franz Castro
44:10.5
And the center left
44:14.4
So left center left
44:19.6
We're seeing embers of that
44:21.1
And yung term na ginamit ni
44:24.9
Dati kong professor
44:27.9
Di ko binabasa si Alex ngayon
44:30.7
Notorious din ako
44:33.1
Ang estudyante doon
44:34.7
Ako yung tipong estudyante
44:36.9
Si Sir Alex sa akin
44:38.5
Ako yung klase ng estudyante
44:40.3
Alam niyo yung first day of class
44:42.2
Titignan yung silabus
44:45.0
Titignan ako ng silabus
44:59.1
Na kung alam nila
44:59.9
Doon ako sa klase
45:03.7
Kasi karen daw ako
45:05.0
Well medyo may pagkakaren ako
45:06.5
Pero in a good way
45:12.2
Bakit wala si Nietzsche
45:13.7
Bakit wala si Dekide
45:15.2
Bakit wala si Foucault
45:17.3
O kulang yung mga reading sentence
45:18.5
Ganyan akong estudyante guys
45:20.1
Kaya daming galit sa akin
45:21.3
Nung college pa lang
45:23.6
Eh hindi ko nakasalanan
45:26.9
I want to learn the most
45:28.9
Nagihirap yung ating mga parents
45:35.5
So I want to make sure
45:36.4
When I go to a class
45:38.3
I have a world class education
45:40.4
Hindi galit si Sir
45:41.2
Kasi pinagdagdag ko yung
45:44.7
Yung idea ng PTSD
45:53.4
Constructive criticism
45:57.9
Where we're coming from
45:59.0
Kaya yun yung brutal to
46:01.4
I know we can do better
46:03.8
I know we can do better
46:06.0
I know the opposition
46:07.0
Can do better than this
46:11.1
I think President Duterte
46:11.9
Was right on Bangsamora
46:13.1
I think President Duterte
46:13.8
Was right to raise
46:14.6
Some questions about
46:16.1
Questions about our
46:18.4
Over dependence on US
46:20.4
But the answers were horrible
46:23.9
Against crime and drugs
46:25.0
But tignan mo namin
46:25.7
Barabaran yung response
46:27.3
With President BBM
46:30.2
A good foreign policy
46:31.5
At least given things
46:35.3
On the domestic front
46:37.1
Going out and saying
46:38.8
Ang supportan natin
46:39.8
In the middle of this
46:46.1
I hope they don't
46:46.8
Take things against us
46:49.8
Independent voices
46:51.1
And hindi naman ako
46:53.9
What I'm talking about
46:55.7
Maybe there's a reason why
46:57.0
All around the world
46:59.1
Dahil maybe they know
47:01.5
Maybe I know something
47:04.8
I'm just a human being
47:05.8
I have my limitations
47:07.1
But the Lord also knows
47:13.6
Like thinking is my life
47:16.7
Kaya tayo nakapagsulat
47:18.9
Kaya tayo nakapag vlogs
47:20.5
Kaya tayo nakainterview
47:21.7
Because I'm constantly
47:24.0
Wala akong time na
47:31.7
Sa mga ganon guys
47:37.4
The rest is just reading
47:39.6
And speaking of reading
47:41.9
Before I sleep nowadays
47:46.2
Ito yung binabasa ko
47:47.2
Ito yung libro ni Rizal
47:49.5
Gandang libro yan
47:50.8
I really suggest it by John Neri
47:52.3
Very very good book
47:54.1
Ma-inspire ka talaga
47:58.3
Yung mga sakripisyon
48:00.6
Mahiya naman tayo
48:02.7
Mahiya naman tayo
48:04.5
Mahiya naman tayo
48:05.9
Mahiya naman tayo
48:07.9
Nakunting ganyan lang
48:10.0
Alis na tayo ng bansa
48:14.1
Atake natin sa Darian
48:15.9
Ang kapal na mukha niya
48:18.4
Ako yung Johnny Kamlety
48:20.4
Baka hindi ka lang nagbabasa
48:24.0
Kaya wala tayong time
48:28.4
Yung sa end ng meeting
48:30.2
Nagroponggi-roponggi
48:31.3
Yung mga kasama ko
48:31.8
Kumuwi na lang ako
48:32.8
Nagvlog na lang tayo
48:35.5
Hindi ako lumalabas sa gabi
48:39.1
I literally have no time
48:44.5
Naiiya ako sa sarili ko
48:46.6
Kung hindi ko ginawa yung best ko
48:48.0
This is the least that I can do
48:50.8
This is the least
48:58.0
Kasi nag-heater ako
48:58.8
Actually malamig dito sa ligay
49:00.1
Sobrang lamig dito
49:03.2
When it's hot and all
49:16.8
Sa mga nakinig sa atin
49:18.2
Na-appreciate nyo itong ginagawa natin
49:20.9
I start with some jokes
49:26.0
But at the end of the day
49:27.5
You see what I'm doing guys
49:29.0
We eventually move towards
49:31.6
A proper serious discussion
49:35.1
You had an introduction
49:37.0
To Hegelian Dialectics
49:38.4
Negation of negation
49:42.6
You're having something
49:46.0
For the detainees
50:12.5
Di ka mam saying.
50:13.7
Di ka mam saying.
50:18.0
before you sleep,
50:18.8
kung mahal yun yung bansa,
50:19.8
manganap kayo ng mga ganitong libro
50:21.0
na may inspire kayo.
50:23.5
I have the time and energy
50:24.7
and all thanks to your support.
50:25.9
I'm hoping to have
50:26.7
something like that.
50:27.7
collection of my writings
50:28.7
and all and all of that
50:30.0
because I'm also writing books
50:35.7
you need something like that
50:40.6
one of the big advices
50:41.6
of Marcos Aurelius
50:44.1
The contemplation of the sage.
50:47.3
na nahihirapan kayo sa buhay,
50:49.1
every time na hindi kayo sure
50:52.8
isipin nyo yung tao
50:56.8
iniidolo is actually blasphemy.
50:58.8
As a man of faith,
51:00.5
I don't want to use that term.
51:01.9
Think of a person
51:02.6
that you look up to.
51:04.9
At sasabihin mo sa sarili mo,
51:06.9
anong gagawin ng taong eto
51:10.0
pag ganito yung kanyang delay,
51:11.6
pag nandito yung problema.
51:14.8
ay ganito or ganyan?
51:16.4
So, the contemplation of the sage,
51:19.4
Very important yan.
51:21.1
nahihirapan ka sa buhay,
51:22.8
every time na gusto mo
51:24.2
every time na naguguloan ka
51:25.9
or confused ka and all,
51:29.0
yung tao na nire-respeto mo,
51:31.2
anong gagawin niya
51:32.0
sa ganitong situation?
51:36.6
as a proud Filipino,
51:37.4
I will always ask,
51:38.4
what would Rizal do?
51:40.1
I'm like Rizal and all of that,
51:43.4
babash na naman ako.
51:45.7
I always ask myself,
51:47.1
what would Rizal do?
51:56.4
would have been a vlogger.
51:59.6
what we're trying to do here.
52:01.6
To write the top publications
52:03.3
around the world,
52:04.1
to do the scholarly work,
52:05.7
to fight the good fight,
52:07.0
but also to vlog.
52:13.4
to be truly humble,
52:15.7
not kunyaring humble,
52:17.2
and to call out nonsense.
52:18.9
To call out nonsense.
52:20.9
Including your own nonsense.
52:25.4
thank you very much.
52:26.8
including sa mga trolls natin
52:28.2
na tinataas yung ating engagement.
52:30.3
I always appreciate that.
52:32.0
I always appreciate that.
52:36.0
and talk to you soon.
52:38.3
And yeah, of course,
52:38.8
there are many, many other great books.
52:40.0
There are other books,
52:41.6
na I'm writing a review,
52:44.5
probably I also have to start doing
52:46.7
serious book reviews and all.
52:51.9
Sons and Fathers and Sons,
52:54.7
and War and Peace,
52:59.0
where is Book of Ambet,
53:00.2
Patricia and Vangelista,
53:03.6
closest to my heart.
53:05.2
The book that I think
53:05.9
was responsible for me,
53:07.1
like Falling in Love
53:07.8
with the Legacy of Our Forefathers.
53:12.1
I can go on and on about it,
53:13.3
but yun lang, guys.
53:16.2
We are serious people.
53:17.9
We joke here and there.
53:19.1
We make humor and all,
53:20.1
but we are serious people.
53:22.0
And God willing, sana,
53:23.5
I can write enough
53:24.4
so that I can put them together
53:25.4
because, you know,
53:26.9
I don't think I can separate,
53:28.6
But I can put something nice together
53:31.2
So, thank you so much, guys,
53:32.7
dito sa continuous support nyo.
53:34.8
Ito yung tiwala nyo sa akin.
53:37.2
nagbibiro lang ako,
53:42.0
nakita nyo talagang
53:43.6
I mean, meron pa rin,
53:44.5
but you could see
53:45.0
I was really, really tired.
53:47.3
sabi ko, go pa rin.
53:49.5
Let's discuss this.
53:50.6
Let's discuss this.
53:52.5
I hope you appreciate
53:55.2
we're doing here.
53:58.4
and talk to you soon.
